Debunking Model View Controller

Created 2005-07-02 / Edited 2005-07-02

In a Web-Application Context

As I have discussed elsewhere (see Thoughts and issues with web-based DB programming), Model-View-Controller is one way of going about complex GUI internals, even in a web-application context. It has quite a few benefits, mostly organizational, which have drawn people like myself to the mindset. I propose, however, that the MVC method and its variants actually work against the object-oriented nature which it is often touted as exemplifying.

It all comes down to the relationship between the Model and the View. Perhaps the raw MVC model has it correct, but implementations of the framework are not.